How to Compare Quotes from a Roofing Company
Most house owners don’t save for a new roof typically, and that’s an effective factor. When the instant arrives, nevertheless, the studying curve feels steep. Quotes arrive with wildly numerous prices, unexpected terms, and line models that don’t evaluate cleanly. I’ve sat at kitchen tables with estate vendors who notion they'd 3 apples to compare, simplest to realize one bid blanketed a complete tear-off and top rate underlayment when a further assumed a single layer overlay and reused the entire flashing. The cheapest wide variety at the web page is more often than not the such a lot expensive mistake at the home.
This manual walks by using the right way to study roofing estimates with a contractor’s eye, find out how to ask for the excellent clarifications, and the way to make the resolution that balances can charge, sturdiness, and assurance give a boost to. If you’re looking “roofing agency close to me” and compiling bids, that's the framework to split a cast roof craftsman business enterprise from a hazardous one.
Start with scope, not price
Every roofing quote expresses a scope of labor, some greater clearly than others. Before evaluating numbers, examine the moves the contractor supplies to perform. A right apples-to-apples contrast lives or dies on scope alignment.
A thorough scope addresses tear-off, deck inspection and restoration, underlayment, ice and water renovation, flashing, ventilation, shingle or panel style, fasteners, facet steel, penetrations, cleanup, and disposal. If two rates range in even a pair of these, your evaluation could be skewed. I as soon as reviewed three bids for a 2,three hundred square foot ranch in a cold local weather. The low bidder disregarded ice and water safeguard totally. The mid bidder blanketed it in any respect eaves and valleys. The high bidder now not handiest protected it at eaves, valleys, and penetrations, yet additionally specified two guides at the eaves due to the roof’s shallow pitch. The payment spread was once basically 30 p.c, but the ones scopes have been now not the similar process.
A riskless roof employer will spell out both thing. If the suggestion is indistinct, ask for a line-by using-line breakdown. A respectable will welcome the request and clarify their reasoning in simple language.
The anatomy of a roofing quote
While formatting varies, maximum respected estimates contain an identical pieces. Understanding them helps you gauge even if a roofing visitors has deliberate your task conscientiously or is guessing.
Tear-off and disposal. This line tells you whether the antique roofing can be removed and the way waste might be handled. A complete tear-off most commonly adds exertions and dumping prices, and it exposes the deck for proper inspection. An overlay avoids those fees however can hide issues and routinely shortens the lifestyles of the brand new roof. There are limited situations where an overlay is suitable, which include a single latest layer in right condition and a architecture engineered to deal with the load, however even then I endorse tear-off if budget makes it possible for.
Deck inspection and restoration. Look for a line object that involves replacement of damaged sheathing. Contractors fee this in two primary tactics: an allowance in keeping with sheet of plywood or OSB, or a now not-to-exceed contingency. If the quote comprises “exchange terrible decking as necessary,” ask what number sheets are incorporated previously a amendment order kicks in and what the in keeping with-sheet value can be. Typical drapery-and-labor fees selection from 65 to one hundred twenty five dollars per sheet relying on thickness, top, and native hard work.
Underlayment and ice barrier. Synthetic underlayments and peel-and-stick ice limitations have enhanced dramatically within the closing 15 years. The estimate ought to specify brand and product grade, not just “manufactured felt.” In snow zones, ice and water maintain at eaves is not really elective, and in my paintings I continue it up at the very least 24 inches contained in the warm inside wall line. Valleys, roof-to-wall intersections, and penetrations also merit ice barrier. Skipping this to shave a couple of hundred dollars is penny-clever, pound-silly.
Shingles or panels. If it’s asphalt, you will have to see the brand, line, and guaranty magnificence. A genuine architectural shingle repeatedly weighs more and contains a longer assurance than budget dimensional shingles. Examples: CertainTeed Landmark, GAF Timberline HDZ, Owens Corning Duration. Metal charges could specify panel profile, steel thickness, paint gadget, and fastening technique. Wood, slate, and tile every single require their personal tips. When estimates say “30-12 months shingle,” ask for the exact product identify. Many “lifetime” shingles have quality print tied to installation practices and air flow.
Flashing. New flashing is the closing place to cut corners. The quote must always embrace replacement of step flashing, counterflashing at chimneys, drip side, and valley steel. Reusing outdated flashing is tempting when the vintage roof comes off cleanly, but historic flashing ordinarilly includes nail holes and fatigue which you won’t see until eventually a leak presentations up. If the roof craftsman plans to reuse some thing, ask why and get that exception in writing.
Ventilation. Roofs fail early when they will not breathe. The estimate should specify consumption (soffit) and exhaust (ridge vent, container vents, gable vents) process. As a rule of thumb, aim for balanced intake and exhaust that meets or exceeds code necessities. On retrofit paintings, I more commonly upload continual ridge vent and reduce the sheathing subsequently, then be certain that soffit vents are open, now not blocked by means of insulation. If a roof craftsman proposes protecting an present gable vent considering the fact that a ridge vent is being further, ascertain the whole device continues to be balanced.
Accessories and fasteners. Nails should always be warm-dipped galvanized or stainless in coastal environments. Staples do no longer belong on a roof. For metal, screw variety and gasket first-rate subject. Starter strip, experienced roofing contractor hip and ridge caps, pipe boots, and sealants should still be named. Low-fee pipe boots can dry out in five years. Upgrading to a bigger-grade boot is low priced coverage.
Cleanup and upkeep. Expect notes approximately estate safety, tarps, magnet rolling for nails, and day-by-day cleanup. If you could have touchy landscaping, air-con items, or a pool, speak about how they're going to be blanketed. On tight web sites, I oftentimes schedule a half day just to installation coverage ahead of tear-off starts off.
Permits and inspections. The quote should point out who pulls the allow and arranges inspections. Some roofers ask householders to tug the let to store on overhead. I choose to see the contractor cope with this, as it indicates they may be willing to be dependable to the building branch.
Making numbers comparable
Once you recognize the scope, positioned the bids into the similar frame. You can do this with a functional table or a brief tick list, however the secret's to normalize changes. If one roof craftsman carries full ice barrier in valleys and the others do no longer, ask the others to revise their bids to suit. If one quote comprises premium ridge vent and the others specify container vents, opt which you decide upon, then request upload or deduct pricing so all three replicate the same method.
I continuously run into bids that use totally different unit assumptions. For instance, one roofer might calculate 25 squares of roofing, every other 28 squares. The big difference would be waste element, overhang, or dimension methodology. Ask both roofing business to provide their measured squares and waste percent. On cut-up roofs with many hips and valleys, waste may possibly reach 15 to 18 %. On plain gable roofs, waste could possibly be in the direction of 8 to 10 p.c.. If a bid is based mostly on unusually low squares, you are able to get a swap order later.
Labor is the quiet variable
Materials are tremendously regular in cost with the aid of zone, however exertions varies large. A roof artisan organization that invests in instruction, security, and supervision will fee more than a pickup-truck crew that can pay dollars on the end of the day. You think that big difference within the main points: immediately guides, top pushed nails, spotless valleys, and tidy flashing work. Those info ensure no matter if your roof survives a wind-pushed rain at 2 a.m.
Ask who will probably be on the roof. Is it the company’s very own staff or subcontractors? Subcontracting isn't inherently negative, however you wish to know who supervises and the way quality is controlled. A respectable roof business will name the foreman who will run your activity and explain how they address punch lists.
Crew measurement and time table rely too. A six-grownup staff can dry in a 2,000 square foot roof in an afternoon if weather is honest. A two-man or woman team may well stretch that over a few days, growing the danger of a hurricane catching the space mid-process. Schedule reality has price that doesn’t convey up in the base expense.
Warranties you could in actuality use
Many rates trumpet “lifetime guaranty.” Read the great print. There are two buckets: enterprise guaranty on substances and contractor guaranty on workmanship. The first covers defects inside the shingles or panels, no longer error in install. The 2d covers leak upkeep through how the roof used to be hooked up.
A sturdy contractor workmanship guarantee runs 5 to 10 years for asphalt and longer for metallic, even though I actually have considered one to 2 years in a few markets. The period things less than the contractor’s willingness to face behind the paintings. I get calls to fix five-yr-historical leaks on roofs set up by way of providers that no longer exist. That is in which the “roofing visitors near me” search pays off. A nearby organization with decades in industry is much more likely to elect up the phone later.
Manufacturer improved warranties require different method and setting up practices. If a roof artisan promises to register an elevated guaranty, ask what parts are required: underlayment, starter, shingles, hip/ridge, and targeted fastener styles. There is mostly a registration charge and regularly an inspection by way of the brand’s rep. This can add expense, yet it makes feel whilst you are already investing in a top class procedure.
Be cautious of workmanship warranties that exclude flashing or skylights thoroughly. Flashing is wherein leaks come about. If exclusions exist, press for rationalization or negotiate assurance that displays authentic possibility.
The sophisticated quotes that swing a bid
A few quiet assumptions can add hundreds and hundreds or hundreds of greenbacks once a task is underway. Clarify them before you sign.
Deck substitute allowance. Nail pops and delamination are trouble-free. Agree on a in keeping with-sheet price and a trigger for owner approval after a exact threshold. I in most cases set the 1st five sheets at the acknowledged cost with no prior approval, then name the proprietor if we find more.
Plywood versus OSB. If the present deck is plank forums, the roof artisan can even endorse overlaying with plywood. Confirm thickness and grade. Half-inch plywood is general, but 5/eight inch improves stiffness on rafters spaced at 24 inches. The fee big difference throughout a whole roof may well be immense.
Chimney and masonry work. Roofing prices most of the time exclude masonry repairs. If the chimney crown or mortar joints are failing, water will discover a means in notwithstanding how superb the flashing is. If your chimney wishes work, take care of it earlier or in the course of the roofing project so the flashing work ties into sound masonry.
Skylights. Old skylights are a leak probability. Reflashing a 20-12 months-old skylight is more affordable than replacing it that day, however if the unit itself fails two winters later you would pay twice for flashing. The prudent circulation is to change aged skylights for the time of re-roofing, especially if they are constant-length scale down units. Ask for upload/alt pricing.
Gutters. Removing and reinstalling gutters to change drip part adds hard work. If your gutters are worn-out, take into accout substitute coordinated with the roof. Discuss coloration, profile, and downspout places within the same communique.
How to vet the service provider behind the quote
Numbers on a page handiest tell component of the story. You are hiring a crew to work at top with nail guns and dumpsters on your home. The accurate due diligence facilitates avoid complications.
Insurance and licensing. Request certificates of wellknown legal responsibility and people’ compensation, issued to you by way of the insurance agent, no longer a photocopy. Verify active licensing wherein required. I have obvious costs that beat the field by way of 20 p.c most effective on the grounds that the bidder carried no employees’ comp. If a worker is injured on your site, you do not wish to stumble on that hole.
Local references. Ask for two recent jobs and one older activity, 5 to 10 years outdated. Drive via if workable. Look at lines, valleys, and flashing terminations. Ask the references how the crew behaved, even if the visitors communicated neatly, and the way they taken care of surprises.

Site control. Clarify get started time, daily conclusion time, and whether work maintains on Saturdays. If you've gotten young people, pets, or a industrial on site, schedule things. Ask how parts and dumpsters will probably be staged and the way they preserve driveways from dumpster wheels or hydraulic jacks. I lay down plywood runners underneath dumpsters and area a magnetic mat on the on daily basis walkway.
Change order course of. Surprises ensue when roofs open up. Good contractors set expectations on how they doc unforeseen prerequisites, price excess work, and get your approval. A fast snapshot with a clear observe and a signature goes a protracted approach.
Communication flavor. Some householders prefer text updates; others wish a morning briefing. Match the roof artisan’s communication rhythm for your selection. A small roof company would possibly offer extra direct get right of entry to to the owner, which will likely be a plus on jobs with many selections.
Reading the weather window
A roof is a weather-touchy mission. When evaluating charges, ask about the deliberate sequence relative to forecast. A seasoned roof artisan watches styles and assists in keeping your home dry first. On tear-off day, I would like no rain hazard above 20 percentage, and I need satisfactory staff to peel and dry-in the similar day. If the roof repairer is booked solid for 6 weeks and your roof is actively leaking, you need a stopgap plan. Temporary maintenance, tarping, or sealing can bridge the gap. A responsive roof supplier will make time for triage.
In scorching climates, operating early and defending shingles from scuffing topics. In cold climates, adhesive strips want warmth to seal top. Your contractor should still comprehend and plan for the ones realities. Ask how they control shoulder seasons and what occurs if climate stalls the task for an afternoon or two.
Price degrees that make sense
Every marketplace has its stages, yet styles repeat. For a truthful tear-off and replace with architectural asphalt on a unmarried-tale home, many regions land around 350 to 650 money in keeping with sq. for hard work and standard constituents, emerging to 700 to one,000 dollars consistent with sq. with top class underlayment, great flashing, and challenging roofs. Metal can fluctuate from 900 to at least one,six hundred cash in line with square for due to-mounted panels, and greater for status seam with hid clips and top rate coatings.
If a bid falls a ways under the local norm, ask what has been excluded or assumed. I reviewed a 24-sq. bid lately at 8,500 money total. It assumed one layer tear-off, zero sheet substitute, reused step flashing, no ice barrier, and home owner supplied dumpster. Once normalized to a complete scope, the price jumped to the middle of the %.
When the bottom expense is the accurate choice
Price on my own shouldn't be a red flag. I actually have presented jobs to the bottom bidder whilst 3 situations lined up. First, the scope matched line for line with the others. Second, the references and insurance plan looked at. Third, the communication signaled competence: the foreman understood air flow ratios, may perhaps give an explanation for nail styles, and did no longer recoil when I asked for the organization’s set up advisor. Sometimes a roofing agency runs a lean operation and passes the savings along. If the roof craftsman enterprise can reveal best, a pointy expense is also a win.
A temporary list for closing selection
- Confirm exact scope across all charges: tear-off, underlayment, ice barrier, flashing, ventilation, supplies, cleanup, allows for.
- Verify measured squares and waste components are equivalent and average for your roof structure.
- Ask for exact product names and grades, adding underlayment, shingles or panels, ridge vent, and flashing metal.
- Review workmanship and corporation warranties in detail, which includes any exclusions.
- Validate licensing, established legal responsibility, and laborers’ comp, and make contact with two fresh references and one older patron.
Use this checklist as a ultimate circulate after you could have carried out the deeper assessment. It assists in keeping the focus on necessities when last numbers tempt you to hurry.
How to architecture money and schedule
A truthful check schedule protects both events. I seldom propose paying more than one 3rd up the front, or even that must align with drapery supply. A general structure is a modest deposit to take care of scheduling, a draw upon supply of supplies, a draw after tear-off and dry-in, and the ultimate upon finishing touch and cleanup. If a roof organization insists on such a lot of the dollars prior to paintings begins, be cautious.
Clarify what “good sized completion” capacity. For roofing, I tie last money to a fresh web site, closing town inspection signed off, and registration of any organization multiplied warranty. Make convinced punch checklist models, including paint contact-united states of america fascia or the replacement of a crushed downspout, are captured in writing.
Special situations that distort quotes
Low-slope sections. Many properties blend steep-slope shingles with low-slope porch roofs or dormers. Low-slope calls for varied substances, characteristically a self-adhered membrane or changed bitumen. Quotes that treat those components like the steep roof will rationale leaks later. Ask for particulars and product information sheets for low-slope quantities.
Historic particulars and cedar. Cedar shake substitute includes thicker underlayment, different air flow processes, and often battens. A roof artisan surprising with wood would value it unsuitable or set up it poorly. If you are exchanging cedar with asphalt, you could possibly want to feature deck sheathing to in attaining a flat substrate. That greater paintings deserve to express up explicitly in the bid.
Complex valleys and dead-stop roof planes. Where roofs dump water into walls or useless valleys, a widely wide-spread mindset gained’t minimize it. I even have fabricated customized crickets and soldered pans for these locations. If your place has one, confirm the roof craftsman has a plan that goes beyond “we’ll flash it.”
Solar and long term penetrations. If you propose to add sunlight inside of a couple of years, coordinate. Pre-setting up mounts or a minimum of clarifying the shingle line’s compatibility with easy sun mount systems can shop cost and keep penetrations that void warranties. If your roof repairer works sometimes with sunlight installers, that’s a plus.
Coastal and high-wind zones. Fastener styles, starter strips, and shingle selection substitute in windy components. The estimate needs to cite compliance with local wind scores. Stainless or top-grade fasteners is perhaps warranted in salt air regions.
The importance of a site visit
Some rates are constructed from aerial measurements. The technologies is desirable on edge and pitch, but it is going to pass over tender decking, hidden valleys, or air flow blockages. I opt for a minimum of one in-consumer seek advice from before a agreement is signed. During that talk over with, stroll the property in combination. Point out ceiling stains, attic get right of entry to, and any previous leak places. Ask the roof craftsman to pop into the attic in short to check air flow and insulation. A short while inside the attic most often saves hours of troubleshooting later.
I once bid a roof with four container vents. In the attic, we discovered soffit baffles overwhelmed by insulation and gable vents pulling air across the attic rather than up and out. We adjusted the plan to steady soffit vents and a ridge vent, closed the gables, and the summer time attic temperature dropped with the aid of nearly 20 levels. That consequence began with a ladder and a flashlight.
Putting all of it together
When you could have 3 or extra charges from roofing enterprises, withstand the urge so as to add them up and select the center. Do the slower paintings first: normalize scope, test measurements, be sure items, and look at various the contractor’s professionalism with genuine questions. Let the charge be the remaining tiebreaker between bids that essentially describe the identical task.
If you are early within the approach and finding a roofing business enterprise close me, use your first calls to examine. Ask every single roof manufacturer how they cope with ice barrier, air flow, and flashing. Listen for clarity, no longer revenues gloss. The roof over your head seriously is not just shingles and nails. It is a method, set up via of us, that has to work in warm, bloodless, wind, and rain for many years. A cautious comparability of fees is your finest leverage to be sure it does.
How can I maintain and extend the life of a flat roof in the Portland climate?
Regular inspections, keeping drains clear, addressing small issues promptly, and managing moss/algae are key to extending the life of a flat roof in Portland’s wet climate. Read more
How much does a roof replacement cost in Portland, OR in 2025?
The average roof replacement in Portland ranges from $10,000 to $22,000 depending on material, roof size, and complexity, with asphalt shingles averaging around $14,000. Read more
What are 5 early warning signs that your Portland home needs a roof replacement?
Look for missing or damaged shingles, sagging areas, moss/algae growth, interior leaks, and an aging roof. Early detection can save on costly repairs. Read more
What services do professional roofing companies typically provide?
Professional roofing companies offer inspections, repairs, replacements, flat and pitched roofing, ventilation upgrades, emergency leak response, and maintenance plans. Read more
How do roofing companies ensure compliance with safety standards and regulations?
Roofing companies comply with OSHA and local building codes through fall-protection, PPE use, proper training, scaffolding safety, and adherence to permitting requirements. Read more
What do customers say about Her Roofing?
Here are some of our Google reviews:
Check all reviews on our Google Maps page.
HER Roofing
Phone: (503) 946-9068
Address: 133 SE 9th Ave #113 Portland OR 97214
Contact HER Roofing today to schedule a consultation or learn more about our professional roofing services.