Roofer Company vs. General Contractor: Who to Hire for Your Roof
Homeowners don’t take into account roofing except water finds a method interior. By then, the clock is ticking. Between soaked sheathing, creeping mould, and the dread of an alternative storm, you want a authentic who knows a way to prevent the ruin and make the roof desirable. The first resolution is primarily the toughest: must always you appoint a devoted roof repairer institution or deliver in a basic contractor to run the assignment? The solution relies upon on scope, probability, timing, warranty, and how tender you are coping with trades.
I’ve run bids on every little thing from 900-rectangular-foot bungalows to twelve,000-square-foot tradition buildings with copper valleys and status seam metal. I’ve viewed jobs move sideways considering the fact that the inaccurate lead was once in charge. I’ve additionally obvious primary contractors rescue elaborate builds that may have buried a unmarried business. If you recognise the distinction among a roofing expert and a generalist builder, you’ll decide the good lead to your roof and avoid paying twice.
What a roofing company really does
Roofing organisations live and die by using how nicely they store water out. They’re provided for elevation work, steep pitches, tear-offs, and climate windows. Most elevate harness kits, toe forums, brake machines for flashing, magnetic sweepers for nails, and sufficient tarps to canopy a small football field. They examine climate radar like pilots and communicate in squares, not sq. ft. When a roof leaks, they do now not have the posh of expecting subsequent week’s schedule.
A able roof artisan provider handles drapery collection, enables tied to roof alternative, waste disposal, and brand specs that secure your guaranty. They have formulation understanding: how ice and water shield interacts with eaves in your local weather area, the way to vent an attic so shingles do not cook from the underside, wherein to area step flashing at a sidewall, and how one can rebuild a chimney cricket so ice doesn’t dam at the back of it. They can tear off and dry-in a 25-square roof in a day when a typhoon is bearing down. That final component matters extra than most owners detect.
You’ll also discover stronger manufacturer get entry to with a true roofing organisation. Many are credentialed via shingle makers or metal techniques, and that repute can liberate longer non-prorated guaranty classes if the service provider installs the complete components. That in general requires exceptional underlayments, starter publications, ridge vents, and flashing kits. A widely used contractor can primarily apply the spec, but a roofing corporation installs that spec weekly and is familiar with where the particulars trip you up, from nail placement to valley cuts.
What a trendy contractor brings to the table
A widely used contractor orchestrates. Think of them as the conductor who pulls in framers, roofers, HVAC, electricians, and insulators within the accurate order, on the desirable days. If your mission touches more than the roof - say you’re including dormers, exchanging sheathing due to structural rot, upgrading skylights, transferring bath fanatics to a new roof penetration, or you prefer to tackle ice dams by means of including outdoors insulation - a conventional contractor is built for that complexity.
General contractors control scope creep and sequencing negative aspects. They can get the framer to sister rafters, coordinate a structural engineer for a ridge beam upgrade, get the electrician to reroute can lights so that you can upload a continual air barrier, and have the drywall crew on call whilst the attic get entry to receives relocated. They handle amendment orders, lien releases, and inspections that pass commerce strains. If you are starting the roof and the residence at the comparable time, you wish one adult in charge of the comprehensive meeting.
There is one capture. Some established contractors self-perform a section of roofing, however many sub the roof to a roof repairer company besides. When that occurs, you pay for coordination and markup, but you achieve the protection of a unmarried level of contact and a warranty that spans the total scope. That business-off may be well worth it for not easy tasks, much less so local roofing contractor for easy re-roofs.
The jobs that belong to a roof artisan company
If you need a like-for-like roof replacement with the comparable layout, fabric category, and no structural differences, rent a roofing institution. This includes 3-tab shingles to architectural shingles, architectural to architectural, asphalt to asphalt with localized deck upkeep, or a status seam steel overlay over reliable decking. The leading roofing firms bite through those effectually and with bigger craftsmanship than a generalist who does it two times a yr.
Emergency leak response also belongs to a roof repairer supplier. When a ridge cap blows off at the hours of darkness or a tree limb punches a hole near the eave, you favor someone who can tarp accurately, then return with matching elements. General contractors can triage and call a roof artisan, however the intermediary step kills time and adds check.
Insurance-pushed hail or wind claims are compatible roofing authorities too. They be aware of the right way to doc shingle bruising, creased tabs, and granule loss, and that they dialogue the adjuster’s language. They’ll battle for code-required ice and water membranes or drip side if your municipality adopted these updates after your own home was once outfitted. That code footing is characteristically the distinction among a patch and a complete alternative.
Finally, guarantee-holding installations are a roofing guests’s bread and butter. If you favor a 20 to 50 year company-backed warranty on shingles or a 20 to 35 year end warranty on steel panels, the brand broadly speaking wants a credentialed installer. If you chase a “roofing brand close me” and land on one of those credentialed crews, you possibly can get extended policy cover you’d not at all see from a generalist.
When a known contractor is the higher choice
There are roofs that aren’t just roofs. If you’re reframing to take away a sagging ridge, reducing new dormers, adding a shed roof over a porch, or changing a vented attic right into a conditioned space with outside insulation and a new air barrier, that’s a customary contractor mission. You nevertheless desire an mind-blowing roof repairer on the crew, however the lead may still be the person that sees the complete assembly from starting place up.
Historic houses complicate everything. I labored on a 1910 foursquare with balloon framing, normal plank sheathing, and a slate roof at conclusion-of-lifestyles. We revealed chimney circulate after tear-off and needed to rebuild the cricket, repoint brick, and add steel angles to stabilize the stack. A roofer may perhaps have laid slate or man made slate beautifully, however the structural and masonry sequencing generally known as for a well-known contractor. Slate and tile additionally elevate magnificent loading, that could push you into structural engineering and new rafters. That is not a single-alternate activity.
Major constructing science upgrades belong with a GC as neatly. If you combat ice dams, the solution may not be warmness cables and prayers. It is perhaps steady exterior insulation above the roof deck, a strong air barrier at the deck level, remodeled soffit-to-ridge ventilation, and corrected tub fan terminations. That involves roofing, carpentry, insulation, mechanical air flow, and sometimes new fascia and gutters. Without a commonly used contractor, you probability most appropriate shingles on a roof that still bureaucracy ice considering the fact that the upstream subject matters not ever were given constant.
Lastly, projects with assorted trades on tight time cut-off dates gain from a GC’s time table administration. If you may have sun planned, an electrical upgrade, and a brand new roof, you want the series refreshing. The roof artisan units the flashings and mounts, the sunlight team sets rails and modules, the electrician pulls the enable and interconnects. A GC who has completed this dance protects your roof assurance and keeps the application inspection not off course.
Skill, defense, and specialization
Both roofing providers and widely wide-spread contractors shall be the best option or awful. The big difference is where their muscle reminiscence lives.
Roofers practice for steep-slope safety, useful tear-offs, water administration facts, and product-unique thoughts. They set harness anchors with no chewing up your rafters, they recognise where to land nailers so fasteners don’t telegraph, and they'll braid a valley reduce that sheds water for decades. On a windy ridge, that ride retains other people on the roof and your home out of hurt’s manner.
General contractors show for coordination, sequencing, and accountability throughout scopes. They are really good at catching dependency dangers. For illustration, in case your attic needs baffles and more effective air sealing, the GC will schedule the insulation crew correct after the roofer cuts in steady soffit vents, now not three weeks later while get admission to is sealed up. They also lift the bigger photo liability that says if a leak ruins drywall inside the visitor bedroom, human being to boot the roofer is liable for making you entire.
Permits, codes, and inspections
Roofing codes differ extensively. Some jurisdictions require enables for overlays, others in simple terms for full tear-offs, and a few on no account unless structural paintings is worried. Ice and water take care of at eaves is usually necessary in snow zones. Drip facet, ridge ventilation, and underlayment specifications exchange with code cycles. A roofing provider working your metropolis on a daily basis will realize the inspector’s preferences, which cuts surprises.
When you pass into structural variations, skylight enlargements, dormers, and chimney rebuilds, the general contractor earns their retain. They coordinate the appropriate makes it possible for, bring in engineering if crucial, and construct to stamped drawings rather than container guesswork. If you choose one guaranty file to duvet the recent headers, insulation, skylights, and roof membrane, you get that from a GC-led assignment.
Cost architecture and wherein the cost goes
Homeowners normally anchor on the range in keeping with sq. and omit how undertaking management affects overall money of possession. Roofing agencies value with the aid of squares, pitch, layers, get entry to, and complexity. Expect adders for steep slopes, diverse layers, rotten deck alternative, skylight flashing, and working round solar or satellite hardware. A properly-run roof artisan agency should be would becould very well be the cheapest route to an both smartly-finished roof on basic jobs.
General contractors add overhead on the grounds that they arrange chance and coordinate trades. On a simple roof, that overhead buys you very little. On a advanced project, it buys you fewer surprises, a single throat to choke, and more advantageous results when scope expands. I actually have viewed GC-managed re-roofs value 10 to 20 percentage greater strictly for the coordination layer. When we found rotten rafters on a Victorian in the heart of January, that 20 % felt affordable, as a result of the GC had a framer and transient warmth on web page the next morning, and the roof was once buttoned up earlier the following snow.
Beware bids that appearance too fabulous to be proper. A low roofing quantity most commonly hides missing line units: plywood, ice and water, fastener upgrades for prime-wind zones, or the rate to update flashing instead of reuse it. Reusing flashings can void your company guarantee and result in leaks at walls and chimneys. If a roofer’s range turns out light, ask what number sheets of deck replacement are included and at what near-check, and even if all flashings will get replaced. On the GC edge, ask for the roofing sub’s call and credential repute ahead of you pay a top class for a mystery staff.
Warranties and lengthy-time period protection
There are two warranties in play: the company’s and the installer’s. Manufacturer warranties rely upon product and installation according to spec. They might possibly be prorated after several years until you improve with a method guarantee thru a credentialed installer. Installer warranties cowl workmanship. A strong roof craftsman employer will be offering labor insurance policy inside the five to 15 12 months latitude for asphalt, longer for metal and uniqueness tactics if they may be hooked up for it. The strongest warranties I’ve visible require the roof repairer to take advantage of the company’s full components and register the job inside of a collection window.
General contractors in general wrap a broader warranty around the total assignment, however the roofing component nevertheless is based on the roofer’s workmanship. If a leak appears to be like at a skylight that the roof artisan flashed however the GC set up, finger-pointing can start. A excellent GC heads that off with clean scopes and single-birthday celebration accountability over roof penetrations and flashing kits.
Always ask who is standing behind the assurance five or ten years out. Some roofers vanish after storm seasons. That’s wherein a strong, in the community rooted roofing employer is valued at more than the bottom value. If you seek “roofing organisation close me” and discover a crew with 10 years in the same handle, vans you spot year-around, and brand backing, you might be much more likely to have somewhere to move if the ridge leaks in 12 months three.
Timing, climate, and logistics
Roofing is climate work. Crews chase dry days, and schedules bloat while storms stack up. Roofers are nimble beneath rigidity. They can tear off at crack of dawn, dry-in by using midday, and shingle through late afternoon if the radar is clean. They level tarps, maintain landscaping, and sweep for nails with magnets since they do it on a daily basis.
General contractors manipulate timing when roofing is one piece of a larger puzzle. If a crane units dormers on Tuesday, the roof craftsman wishes to be equipped Wednesday. If insulation demands to land formerly the roof shingles for an over-deck insulation approach, the GC guarantees that truck displays up on time. In shoulder seasons, the GC additionally coordinates short-term warmness to get adhesives and membranes to bond desirable. On EPDM and TPO low-slope sections, temperature can make or damage adhesion.
From a home-owner’s viewpoint, make sure the settlement addresses weather maintenance. I’ve considered crews rip off more than they are able to dry-in, then spend a night preventing gusts with tarps. A disciplined roof artisan will merely open what they may be able to near that day. A disciplined GC will display screen that conduct and halt a tear-off previously a hurricane window if considered necessary.
Roof parts and who handles them best
Asphalt shingles are the majority of residential work. Experienced roofing establishments can lay architectural shingles effectively, layer in properly starters and edges, set ridge ventilation, and integrate bath and kitchen vents with the true boots. A universal contractor adds little fee unless the assignment has structural or construction science complexity connected.
Standing seam metallic is a distinct animal. Coil resolution, panel forming, clip spacing, thermal flow, and end care rely. The difference between a favorable and undesirable metallic roof exhibits up in oil canning, scratched panels, and leaks at skylights after the primary demanding freeze. Hire a roof craftsman employer with in-apartment metal strength or a committed steel sub familiar for residential paintings. A GC can coordinate, but the steel craft lives with the roof craftsman.
Slate, clay tile, and cedar shake require craftspeople who remember weight, fasteners, and underlayment preferences. Slate and tile need strengthened framing in lots of instances, plus careful copper or stainless flashing. Cedar wishes ventilation, preservative medication, and a rainscreen method in some climates. These should not hand-me-down potential. If a GC leads, ensure the roof artisan’s portfolio carries the exact material and roof sort.
Flat or low-slope sections on differently pitched roofs complicate matters. If your private home has a low-slope porch tie-in or a rear addition with a membrane roof, the roof craftsman desires TPO, EPDM, or changed bitumen trip. The information at transitions - wherein the membrane meets shingle - are leak magnets whilst carried out poorly. Ask to peer a done process with the equal particulars, not just a brochure.
The hidden dangers that opt the choice
Beneath shingles, you could uncover spongy sheathing, undersized rafters, lower trusses from an historical attic conversion, or a knotted mess of bath fan hoses venting into the attic. Roofers can update sheets, fix evident rot, and redirect vents with the aid of new roof jacks. If the downside consists of structural fixes, insulation layout, or ventilation approach, a roofer negative aspects solving the symptom at the same time missing the trigger. That’s where a GC earns their cost.
On the turn side, a few GCs depend on lowest-bid roofers and think fine will comply with. If the GC doesn’t recognise roofing small print, you could turn out with enormously shingles over negative flashing or a ridge vent that starves when you consider that the soffits weren’t opened. I’ve considered incredible remodels capped via roofs that fail in six years on the grounds that no person owned the roofing craft.
The cleanest technique is function readability. If the roof is the superstar of the prove, hire a roof artisan corporate to guide. If the roof is a chapter in an extended story - structural exchange, dormers, insulation overhaul, included solar, historical restoration - hire a GC and insist on a named, credentialed roof artisan as the roofing sub.
How to vet your options
Use your neighborhood community first. Neighbors who replaced a roof 3 to five years in the past are the nice barometer. The shine of a new roof fools absolutely everyone; time exposes workmanship. If you look up a roofing friends near me, tournament the online opinions to precise addresses and ask for footage of performed roofs on your local. Drive by using. Look at flashing traces, ridge vents, and how valleys care for debris after a typhoon.
For both a roof artisan enterprise or local HER Roofing Contractor regularly occurring contractor, insist on proof of insurance coverage and employees’ repayment. Elevation paintings contains risk, and you don’t want that possibility to your owner of a house’s policy. Verify licensing where required by way of your country or metropolis. Ask to peer corporation credentials for the unique product you choose. For instance, when you plan on a accomplished shingle technique with an increased guaranty, make sure the corporate’s repute with the organization.
Ask approximately website management. How do they safeguard landscaping and windows for the time of tear-off? Will they use plywood paths for wheelbarrows on mushy lawns? Do they magnet sweep the backyard and driveway day to day? Which character, by way of name, would be on web site coping with the workforce?
Clarify scope in writing. Deck replacement worth per sheet, flashing alternative in preference to reuse, chimney therapy, skylight model and flashing equipment, variety of pipe boots, medication of bath fan terminations, ridge vent sort, and underlayment grade needs to all be spelled out. For a GC-led process, pass further. Define obligation for penetrations, sequencing with insulation and HVAC, and who restores inner finishes if a leak occurs right through development.
A fast determination guide
- Hire a roofing corporate while the assignment is a undemanding substitute, you wish the maximum roofing device guarantee, you desire emergency service, or the scope stays above the deck with constrained carpentry.
- Hire a frequent contractor whilst the roof intersects with architecture, insulation strategy, dormers or additions, skylight enlargements, ancient materials, or integrated sunlight, and also you would like one agreement that covers all transferring components.
A true-world instance for instance the difference
A consumer with a Seventies colonial referred to as approximately routine ice dams and ceiling stains above a bay window. Two past “fixes” had failed: warm cables and new shingles. The attic had nominal insulation, no baffles, bath fanatics dumping into the attic, and the bay roof tied right into a low-slope membrane with a lifeless-finish valley. A roofing friends may well re-shingle and add ice and water defend, but that may handiest hold up the ice, now not stop it.
We ran the venture as a GC-led task with a devoted roof craftsman as a named subcontractor. Scope incorporated vented soffit retrofit, continual baffles, air sealing on the attic ground with two-aspect foam at best plates, rerouting tub enthusiasts to devoted roof caps, reframing the useless-give up valley to a cricket, and replacing the low-slope membrane with a accurate flashed tie-in to shingles. The roofer owned all external penetrations and membranes. The insulation workforce observed immediate after soffit work, and the electrician taken care of the bathtub lovers ahead of the roof dried-in.
That iciness, the eaves stayed sparkling. Not via stronger shingles, however for the reason that the construction now breathed and shed water as a technique. A roof repairer alone would have carried out the visible work. The GC-led system solved the lead to.
Red flags to avoid, no matter who you hire
Beware cash discounts that evade makes it possible for. That would possibly retailer some hundred funds as we speak and check lots in case you sell or when a organization denies a warranty claim. Be cautious of crews that advocate reusing flashings except the materials is metallic in fabulous shape and the manufacturer makes it possible for it. If any person says air flow is non-obligatory, prevent interviewing. In snow zones, insist on a plan for ice and water take care of at eaves and in valleys; in high-wind regions, ask about fastener styles and shingle scores.
Storm-chaser clothing flood neighborhoods after hail. Some are official; many are not. If a guests lists no regional cope with, ameliorations its name mostly, or will not express local references older than year, hinder having a look. A good roof corporate builds a status you might make sure.
Final advice in the past you sign
Match the leader to the dilemma. If your roof is leaking and the format is sound, a roofing institution with the true credentials would be quicker, sharper on data, and more can charge-triumphant. If your roof is portion of a bigger upkeep or has chronic issues tied to air flow, layout, or additions, a known contractor needs to be your quarterback, with a confirmed roof craftsman on the roster.
Get 3 bids, apples to apples, with the same scope, resources, and assurance phrases. Do a site walk with every bidder and concentrate to how they communicate about your roof. The gold standard pros consider two actions ahead. They do not promise miracles, they clarify change-offs. If they deal with your questions about ice dams, ridge ventilation, and flashing with out evasion, you’ve chanced on anyone who can construct a roof that lasts.
And if you’re starting from scratch, lookup a roofing business near me and brief-checklist businesses with a real workplace, continuous crews, and paintings you're able to pressure through. If the venture is greater, seek a commonplace contractor who names their roofing spouse inside the inspiration and isn’t shy about previous jobs it is easy to check up on. Good roofs are outfitted by using individuals who appreciate water and gravity. Great initiatives are led by way of pros who realize while to bring in the excellent consultants and while to step back with the intention to do their premiere work.

How can I maintain and extend the life of a flat roof in the Portland climate?
Regular inspections, keeping drains clear, addressing small issues promptly, and managing moss/algae are key to extending the life of a flat roof in Portland’s wet climate. Read more
How much does a roof replacement cost in Portland, OR in 2025?
The average roof replacement in Portland ranges from $10,000 to $22,000 depending on material, roof size, and complexity, with asphalt shingles averaging around $14,000. Read more
What are 5 early warning signs that your Portland home needs a roof replacement?
Look for missing or damaged shingles, sagging areas, moss/algae growth, interior leaks, and an aging roof. Early detection can save on costly repairs. Read more
What services do professional roofing companies typically provide?
Professional roofing companies offer inspections, repairs, replacements, flat and pitched roofing, ventilation upgrades, emergency leak response, and maintenance plans. Read more
How do roofing companies ensure compliance with safety standards and regulations?
Roofing companies comply with OSHA and local building codes through fall-protection, PPE use, proper training, scaffolding safety, and adherence to permitting requirements. Read more
What do customers say about Her Roofing?
Here are some of our Google reviews:
Check all reviews on our Google Maps page.
HER Roofing
Phone: (503) 946-9068
Address: 133 SE 9th Ave #113 Portland OR 97214
Contact HER Roofing today to schedule a consultation or learn more about our professional roofing services.